CRA toolkit menu
Participation resources |
This section introduces the overarching subject of 'Participation'. This approach to development underpins the application of Community Based Disaster Risk Management (CBDRM) and, in particular, Community Risk Assessment (CRA). Participation has been discussed, studied and applied in various ways in many sectors since the days of so-called 'community development' in the 1950s and 1960s. This section introduces the core debates and most useful participatory resources for those concerned with risk reduction and is structured as follows:
-
Portals and key websites
Networks
Key publications and conceptual articles
Leading thinkers on PAR, RRA, and PRA and their context
- Paulo Freire
- Robert Chambers
Participatory action research
- PAR gateways and key websites
- PAR essays
- PAR applications
Civil society vs. state relations
1. Portals and key websites
- FAO's portal to participation
- GTZs participation portal
- IDS Sussex participation homepage
- IIED PLA Notes
- Citizen participation links [This is more oriented toward political participation and deals a good deal with Eastern Europe; however, there are also essays on the use of PAR in LDC development.]
- Eldis Participation Resource Guide
- Eldis participation manuals and toolkits
- USAID Participation resources
2. Networks
- Participation.net [Especially good access to a range of discussion lists on participation.]
- Resource Centres for Participatory Learning and Action
- Participatory Action Research Network monitored by Cornell University [PARnet aims to create a self-monitored, community-managed knowledge base and gateway to action research resources, connecting practitioners and scholars with each other, the literature, and other educational opportunities.]
3. Key publications and conceptual articles
- The World Bank Participation Sourcebook
- The World Bank: Voices of the Poor: Reports
- Learning from Poor People's Experience: Immersions. Lessons for Change in Policy and Organisations No 13
- Inter-American Development Bank Resource Book on Participation
- UNDP Sustainable Livelihoods; "Empowering People: A Guide to Participation"
- DFID ODA Note on Enhancing Stakeholder Participation in Aid Activities
- Partnerships Online, The Guide to Effective Participation, David Wilcox
- Benfield Hazard Research Centre, Guidance Notes on Participation and Accountability
- Institute for Development Studies, Pathways to Participation
- UNDP/ Office of Evaluation and Strategic Planning. Who are the question-makers? A Participatory Evaluation Handbook
- Feinstein International Center, Participatory Impact Assessment: a Guide for Practitioners
4. Leading thinkers on PAR, RRA, and PRA and their context
Paulo Freire
Paulo Freire taught adult literacy in the early 1960s in very poor neighbourhoods in Recife in northeast Brazil. His experience led him to formulate an alternative view of education - one that saw the creation of knowledge as issuing from the partnership and dialogue between "teacher" and "student." Freire, who died in 1997, is one of the creators of participatory action research, arguably its father.
- Paulo Freire Institute
- UCLA's Paulo Freire Institute
- UNESCO site on Freire's work
- Freire on "Critical Pedagogy on the Web"
- Brief bio and principal writings.
- Reflect: Application of Freire's theory (see also: http://www.actionaid.org.uk/323/reflect.html)
Robert Chambers
Twenty years after Freire's early experiments with "the pedagogy of the oppressed," Chambers wrote his classic book, Rural Development: Putting the Last First. In a recent autobiographical essay, he acknowledges many mistakes he made as development administrator and researcher in the 1960s and 1970s in Africa. Fruit of that humility is the rest of his work that traced and to some degree led to the widespread use of local knowledge for development action (See: "Critical Reflections of a Developmental Nomad," in: Uma Kothari, ed., A Radical History of Development Studies, pp. 67-87. London: Zed Press, 2005).
Brief bio and principle writings
Last First Network (inspired by Chambers' 1983 book, Rural Development: Putting the Last First")
Robert Chambers' classics: brief description and ordering details:
- Robert Chambers, Rural Development: Putting the Last First, 1983
- Robert Chambers, Farmer First: Farmer Innovation and Agricultural Research Edited by Robert Chambers, Arnold Pacey and Lori Ann Thrupp - 1989
- Robert Chambers, Whose Reality Counts? Putting the First Last, 1997
- Robert Chambers, Participatory Workshops: A Sourcebook of 21 Sets of Ideas and Activities, 2002
- Robert Chambers, Andrea Cornwall, John Gaventa, Sammy Musoki and Jethro Pettit Participatory Learning and Action: Critical Relections: Future Directions, 2005
- Robert Chambers, Ideas for Development: reflecting forwards (IDS working paper 238)
5. Participatory action research
The key word in the phrase, PAR, is "action." Although PAR takes many forms across the globe and has focused on areas as diverse as health, agriculture, livestock production and health, forestry, education - as well as hazard risk reduction - the common feature is the iterative: study, plan, act, study, revise plan, act again…
PAR gateways and key websites
- Open Forum on Participatory Geographic Information Systems and Technologies
- Action research resources [A very solid compendium of sources on "action research" which overlaps a good deal with "participatory" research, and, as such, is the broader conceptual home for CRA.]
- Gateways to information on participatorion in Agriculture Research for Development
- Society for Participatory Research in Asia [Strong and well developed center for some 17 years.]
- Green Map System
PAR essays
- Good intro essay focused on "participatory research" and guide to resources by Peter Taylor, IDS Sussex
- Another introductory essay focused on "action research"
- Can PRA yield hard data? [The big question of how one combines qualitative and quantitative data is addressed in this short but provocative piece.]
- FAO brief essay on benefits and obstacles to PAR
- IDS, Pathways to Participation "Critical Reflections on PRA"
- ITC, "Participatory Mapping and Participatory GIS (PGIS) for CRA, Community DRR and Hazard Assessment", by M.K. McCall, September 2008.
- Practical ethics for PGIS practitioners, facilitators, technology intermediaries and researchers, by Giacomo Rambaldi, Robert Chambers, Mike McCall and Jefferson Fox, Participatory Research and Action 54, April 2006
- IISD Critical evaluation of impact of PAR on local capabilities
- PAR in community health
- Cooke and U. Kothari, eds., Participation: The new tyranny? London: Zed, 2001. Ordering information at: http://zedbooks.co.uk/
- S. Hickey and G. Mohan, Participation: From tyranny to transformation? London: Zed, 2004. Ordering information at: http://zedbooks.co.uk/
PAR applications
Key websites
- PPGIS Observatory Website
- Philippine site using PAR for indigenous rights and local knowledge
- West African Rice Development Center (WARDA)
- PRAXIS India: Institute for Participatory Practices
- Participatory GIS and community mapping
- Consortium on International Agricultural Research (CGIAR) system wide gender and PAR research
- International Network on Participatory Irrigation Management
- Proceedings of the first world participatory GIS conference "Mapping for Change International Conference on Participatory Spatial Information Management and Communication", Nairobi, 2005
Examples of practical applications
- Agricultural applications W. Uganda
- Building local development in Latin America: Experiences’ analysis / La construcción del desarrollo local en América Latina: Análisis de experiencias [A bilingual source]
- Urban Agriculture and Forestry applications (RUAF), PRA Tools on Gender and Agriculture
- Sustainable Agriculture And Natural Resource Management (International Development Research Centre- IDRC), Three-Volume Sourcebook Set
- Participatory Methodologies and Participatory Practices: Assessing PRA in the Gambia
- Public Participation in Environmental Impact Assessments in Developing Countries: Index of Useful Resources
- Participation as a process. A success story of the education system in Yemen
- Community water supply management application
- Sanitation application in Bangladesh
- Solid waste management application in Mali
- Vector born disease prevention application in Sarawak
6. Civil society vs. state relations
The word "participation" implies the existence of another agent or stake holder besides the group engaged in PAR. This is often the government. Even when actions are mediated by a non-governmental organization, all communities do is influenced by what governments and other sectors such as private enterprises do (and omit to do) at international and national scales. Communities, rural and urban, may study their own vulnerabilities and capacities to cope. They may embark on action plans. However, at a certain stage, their self protection must imply a degree of social (e.g. state-based) protection as well. At best communities can be partners of the state in reducing risk. At worst, they must attempt to protect themselves from the lack of government investment in social protection or collusion with interests that undermine community and environmental resilience.